5 reasons NHS commissioning is failing late old age

On Tuesday the Health Select Committee inquiry on NHS commissioning heard from Age UK, alongside Mind, National Voices and the Patients’ Association. I was asked how the NHS could save £20 billion over the next four years, without harming healthcare. In my response I argued that savings on this scale would only be possible if we fundamentally change what and how the service commissions, in order to equip the NHS for an ageing nation. I set out five giant failings in NHS support for later life today:

  1. People in late old age have not fully shared in improved health outcomes with respect to the main ‘killer’ diseases of cancer, heart disease and stroke. Our death rates for younger ages now fair well compared to other developed nations, but fall behind for people aged over 75. This indicates a system with in-built age discrimination; a recent example was exposed in a study on GP referral decisions reported in the BMJ this month. More explicit age discrimination continues in pockets too, most noticeably in access to mental health services.
  2. The NHS continues to under-commission vital community and preventative healthcare used mainly in later life: audiology, chiropody, ophthalmology, falls prevention services; and care and support for people with incontinence, depression, osteoporosis and arthritis. None of these are glamorous ‘life or death’ services but together they have a huge impact on keeping people well, in their own homes and avoiding the need for expensive, acute care.
  3. Our health services are failing to adequately support people with complex needs – often in late old age, coming towards the end of their lives. With so many older people using services, every health professional can expect to see people with complex, overlapping health problems; acute frailty; and cognitive impairment. But we organise too much of our healthcare, and train our workforce, on a ‘condition specific’ basis, rather than expecting that everyone is able to adopt a geriatric care perspective, focused on the whole person not the presenting health need. Recent strategies on end of life and dementia are only starting to scrape the surface. The first priority now should be to address the scandalous under-commissioning of GP services for hundreds of thousands of care home residents.
  4. In too many places services still operate in silos and fail to offer people a coherent package of support across organisational boundaries. The most obvious failure is the lack of integration between social care and the health service, despite recent announcements on the tariff for emergency readmission and NHS spending for re-ablement. But there are similar problems in the hand-off between primary, community and acute services within the NHS, and between services focused on different health conditions. We need a fundamental change in the patient journey, so that people receive a coherent range of care and support, closer to home, with the support to manage their own health conditions and retain as much control as possible over their own lives. It’s not an original point, but turning rhetoric into reality is painfully slow, with a strong cultural and institutional bias in favour of acute hospital care.
  5. Finally, the NHS still fails to put dignity and patient experience at the heart of all that it does. People using services and their families still too often feel like an afterthought, with poor communication, lack of involvement in decisions, and inadequate support for basics such as eating, drinking and using the toilet. Much of this is down to attitudes and common sense at the frontline, but without a strong steer from commissioners that the patient experience really matters, dignity will always remain way down the list of priorities.

It reads as quite a depressing list. But in some cases there are obvious solutions. It is imperative, for example, that the Department of Health revises its proposals for the NHS Outcome Framework which would currently only prioritise ‘premature’ deaths up to the age of 75. But many of the answers are more complex and far reaching. In our view the solutions require national leadership, and sustained professional collaboration and commitment at local level – with a greater role for experts in older people’s care at both levels. I worry that the proposals for NHS commissioning reform will at best be a distraction, and at worst could strip the service of its ability to respond to complex, strategic challenges, such as ageing.

To mitigate this risk, we hope the new NHS Commissioning Board will be tasked to take on big-picture system-wide issues, by launching fundamental reviews that set out how and why to achieve transformational change in the services the NHS commissions. A good place to start would be an inquiry on the NHS’s response to ageing.

2 responses to “5 reasons NHS commissioning is failing late old age

  1. I agree with all of thecomments made by Andrew. I also believe that there is a frightening lack of care and respect for the elderley in our hospitals. I have over the past few years witnessed these failings in my local hospital, Addenbrookes in Cambridge. Last week my mother was transferred to a busy geriatric ward. We were told that she had very little chance of surviving through the night. In fact she passed away that evening after having being admitted early morning. There was no dignity afforded to her dignity or any respect given to her conditition. It was a noisy ward, the dear old lady opposite to her was incontinent and falling out of bed. Other patients on the ward complained about their treatment. She did not die in a paeceful atmosphere. I have visited my father and other close relatives in these F and G geriatrics over the years and it has saddened me to see just how they have been treated. I had been a supporter of a pallative care unit in Cambridge, Lord Byron ward, this has been closed for a couple of years now. This unit gave people comfort and respect and the end of life. This unit is now a rehab unit. I believe that when an elderly person is released from hospital, that they should be able to spend two weeks at least to adjust to home return in such a unit. Often they need to therapy to adjust to walking, cooking, bathing and generally getting back to normal life. Most of these people have after all paid national insurance and taxes for most of their lives!

  2. My mother was unfortunate enough to b an inpatient at Chase Farm hospital. The care providers was disgusting, the nurses barely spoke English and were very dismissive and impolite. Most of these nurses should not even be working for the NHS. The Doctors were unhelpful and arrogant. I wouldn’t take my dog to Chase Farm Hospital for treatment, let alone a family member. God help us all!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s